Geothermal savings negate upfront costs
It’s too soon to know how much he’ll save on his monthly energy bills, but Dave Maas has been pleased so far with his home’s new geothermal heating and cooling system.
“It seems to have heated the house on cold days and seems be cooling our house much better than our old system on warm days,” said Maas, New Palestine.
Geothermal units tap into energy that comes from heat sources deep in the earth, eliminating the need for fuel to heat or cool a home. The units use a loop system in which piping is buried underground and brings heat from the earth into the home during the winter. In the summer, it does the reverse and draws heat from the home back into the earth.
“The only downside I’ve experienced with the system had to do with the fact they had to tear up my backyard in order to put the loop in,” Maas said.
Geothermal units actually produce more energy than it takes to operate them. It’s clean energy with few carbon emissions, and delivers up to $5 of energy for every $1 used. That translates into an efficiency rating of 500 percent. By comparison, the best gas furnaces are about 95 percent efficient.
Maas began researching heating, ventilation and air-conditioning systems after deciding it was time to replace his 23-year-old furnace and air conditioner.
Geothermal systems cost more than traditional systems — Maas estimates he spent about $15,000 for his. But homeowners can recoup 30 percent of a unit’s cost through an energy federal tax credit. Lower energy bills also mean year-round savings.
“It made the number come out a lot closer between a traditional heat pump furnace system and a geothermal system,” Maas said of the savings. “I thought for the long run, the geothermal made more sense for me, so I went ahead and paid the higher price — with the understanding that next year I’ll get the tax credit applied to my tax return.”
The U.S. Department of Energy says 43 percent of the typical homeowner’s energy bill goes toward heating and cooling. Geothermal heat pumps are highly efficient and cost little to operate.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency estimates homeowners with geothermal systems can save 30 percent to 70 percent on heating and 20 percent to 50 percent on cooling costs over conventional systems.
Not every heating and cooling company installs geothermal units, so it’s important for homeowners to do their research before making a purchase. Loop installers are certified by the International Ground Source Heat Pump Association.
Industry experts estimate that geothermal units, which also heat water in homes, will average twice the lifespan of traditional heating and cooling units.
The units are self-contained, so there is no separate air-conditioner, and they operate more quietly than conventional units.
“It’s considered green technology,” said Rusty Burch, owner of Plainfield-based Total Comfort Solutions. “It’s really a super quiet operation. You can hardly hear it running.”
Posted in groups: Green
best gas furnaces, geothermal heating and cooling system, geothermal heating and cooling, geothermal units, dave maas, geothermal system, geothermal systems, old furnace, furnace system, new palestine, carbon emissions, deep in the earth, heating ventilation and air conditioning, federal tax credit, heat pumps, typical homeowner, cold days, heat sources, energy bills, loop system, Home & Garden, living, greentop, greennews
This article is so full of errors it is ridiculous to point them out! At least 90% is wrong. The efficiency and cost discussion is pure crap!
I have had both geothermal and traditional air-to-air heat pumps. The cost of replacing my geothermal system (not including the ground loop) was just under $10k (top of the line Water Furnace, made in Ft Wayne), year: 1999. In my current home, I had the top of the line Lennox air-to-air heat pump PLUS the top of the line gas furnace PLUS the top of the line air filtration systen PLUS a humidifier installed for $9660, year 2007. I have a 2000 sq ft home. Highest gas bill last year was $130. Highest AC electric bill last summer was $135. That’s at least as low as any electric bill I had with geothermal in 1999, less with inflation factored in. As far as noise: geothermal is way louder! My Lennox system is so quiet you can hardly tell it is on. And the outdoor unit is so unbelievably quiet!!
And one other thing, the ground loop in my previous home sprung a leak! You don’t want to know the cost to have that fixed! And if you don’t have a yearly maintenance contract for the system (so they can refill the loop with water), running geothermal without water in the loop will freeze it up and also burnout relays and/or contacts on the compressor. I’m speaking from experience! This may not be covered on warranty.
Go with a good quality air-to-air…it’s cheaper to buy and operate and service.
I would have to totally diagree. No doubt that some people have had bad experiences with geothermal however, I really like mine. My total heating and cooling cost last year was $960.00. You can stand next to the unit and barely hear it running. I have friends that have had geothermal in the past and the units lasted nearly 20 years and never had problems with the loops. Expensive to install Yes! I would think that with tax credits and energy savings you could see a payoff in less than 10 years.




2 comments